I've had them in 265/75R16 since june 2016. The first summer I tried hard provoking them to aqua planing without success, and found them very stable in all kinds of conditions. Today, in the fifth year, I managed a tiny bit of aqua planing on one wheel, going 90-95 km/h on the highway when hitting a small puddle in a groove.
All in all they are very stable, wet and dry, cold and warm. Not noisy and even usable in snow when new. I run 36 psi normally.
That they have a shorter lifespan than earlier version, indicates that the rubber has better friction/grip.
Always go with the narrower option if possible. It will generally give you better handling, better friction, less wear on both tyres and suspension components, less power steer, and better economy.