Just seen this really interesting thread and hope I can add some intel and ask for some in return.
I've got a '96 Surf with the 1KZ-TE motor. Cracking vehicle, used for everything from heavy towing to continental touring. 240k kms on the clock and going like a swiss watch. Never uses any coolant. Only ever had two problems with it (well the same problem, twice) - Overheating, fully laden on fast, long motorway inclines. Only happenned twice but both times the same, fully loaded, long hill, pedal hard down as usual (!) 80-85 mph, sudden but partial loss of power, look down - temp gauge is in the red then a few seconds later swings back to below normal, power returns and we're off again.
I've fitted an aftermarket temp gauge (sender fitted in top hose) to see what's going on and the readings are interesting.
- In normal driving the temp never gets anywhere near 80'c suggesting the thermostat is closed and the engine is still managing to cool itself (cabin heater always good and hot so I don't think the stat is stuck open)
- In motorway driving the temps climb slowly up to 82 degrees then come straight back down to 50ish before climbing slowly back to 82, then crashing back to 50ish. This continues for the whole journey. Suggests the stat is opening, letting a slug of cold water from the rad into the engine and then closing again. Thermal cycling like this can't be good for the block and head. Interestingly the factory temp gauge never moves from horizontal, but the aftermarket gauge can be reading anywhere between 50-80'c!
I agree with the guys above - on a long incline the engine temp is climbing faster than the system can cope with and goes into overheat before the stat can open and keep it cool. Also totally agree the factory temp gauge is cr@p!
I'm planning a bit a cooling system overhaul as I really don't want a cracked head. I'm planning to flush the whole system, acid wash the rad, fit a 76'c 'stat and change the fluid in the viscous coupling, However I recon as others do that the 'stat in the bottom hose design is a bit flawed and will still lead to thermal cycling. I'm keen to look into fitting a stat in the top hose.
Two questions:-
- Has anyone else with an aftermarket temp gauge seen similar temp behaviour or have a just got a sticky stat?
- Can anyone who has fitted a top-hose thermostat provide any info on what parts they used, where they were sourced etc?